I think the story of how I decided to write about Sloan is one a very Canadian one. I was listening to political podcast called Curse of Politics, and one of the hosts Kory briefly mentions how the song "The Other Man" is about one of Sloan's lead singers (Chris Murphey) being in a love triangle with Leslie Feist (of Feist) and Andrew Whiteman (of Broken Social Scene). It's super small town gossip feeling...but the whole country is that town.
*I'm going to shoehorn in here that while doing research on "The Other Man", I discovered that there's a radio edited version that has an acoustic guitar intro, which is what my memory recollects (probably because I heard it on a car radio more often). Apparently it's so one can hear the intro on a car radio, according to a Reddit source.
That's what Canadian gossip is though. I didn't read no relationship articles in a magazine about Sloan, Broken Social Scene, or Feist at that time. But hearing about this sounds pretty dang plausible (and confirmed by Chis), as all the Canadian bands in that 2000s indie music era seemed to know each other. And you know, sometimes date. It's small town feeling because these are all bands that never made it outside Canada; compared to say Avril Lavigne marrying Chad Kroeger of Nickelback, which was all over the magazines. And so, only we really know these people or care about any gossip. Ok ok, you can argue Feist did pretty good with the song "1,2,3,4". If you make it on Sesame Street, I think you made it.
Sloan is an interesting band because they seemingly chose to stay in Canada, instead of listening to the big record label (Geffen) and be the next "it" international grunge band. Although some members of Sloan, in a previous band called Kearney Lake Rd, did play at the Rivoli and according to some Torontonians, that's THE big deal.
As they were waiting for Geffen to release Sloan's first EP Peppermint, they started their own record label called Murderecords, so that they could release their music earlier then Geffen could. The label also released projects from bands in Halifax and promoted their scene on the East coast (examples in the "Similar Bands to Check Out" section below). Looks like the label is still running in 2026.
The album Twice Removed was the last project released under Geffen. When asked to re-record the album and sound more like their previous album Smeared, Sloan said "nah man we are good, we like Velvet Underground and Pavement now" (in my imagination that's how it went). There was also the 'issue' of Sloan having no lead singer, as all four members of the band split everything evenly when it comes to song writing and singing. Apparently having a democratic band makes it harder to promote them as well.
Needless to say, the album was not promoted and it was considered a 'failure'. However as time went on, this album has only gained acclaim. With promotion from MuchMusic and college radio stations, Sloan were able to remain stars within their home country. Spin Magazine put Twice Removed on their "Best Albums You Didn't Hear in 1994" list. Then later in 1996, a Canadian publisher Chart magazine ran a reader poll to determine the best Canadian album of all time, and “Twice Removed” took the top spot. When the magazine ran the same poll in 2005, they were on top again. There was also SloanNet, which is an example of the first music fan community on the World Wide Web, that got an organic online community hyping the band.
I think this is all an example of what can happen when faced with failure. You can cave to it, or you can use it to fuel your resolve. Sloan stuck to what makes them unique and stayed the underdog. We got to keep them in small town Canada, and we are proud to call them ours.
_____________________________________________________________
Highlighted song and lyrics:
Coax Me - "If I dink concentrated OJ/ Can I think consolidated's okay?"
______________________________________________________________
Similar bands to check out:
Eric's Trip, The Super Friendz, The Inbreds, Thrush Hermit,
_______________________________________________________________
Links to check out:
Sloancast (part 1 and 2) - Retrospective
Ongoing History of New Music - Interview with Sloan
Winnipegfreepress.com - Retrospective
Intimate and Interactive - Live performance in Toronto

